The Big List of Classic Winter Mystery Novels and Christmas Crimes
This post may contain affiliate links, including Amazon.com. Click here to read my affiliate policy.
Banish the bleak midwinter with a cozy, snow-filled mystery enjoyed with your favourite cup of hot cocoa or tea! These mystery novels set in the wintertime are the perfect atmospheric reads to savor the season.

When it’s cold outside, there’s nothing quite like cozying up with a good mystery novel, snug and safe in your own warm home. And it’s particularly satisfying when the mystery you read suits the season. A snowy novel equals a comfortable reader.
This winter, I’m sharing my list of holiday whodunnits and snowy mysteries to give you plenty to read during those times you don’t feel like venturing out. There’s a cornucopia of good winter-themed mysteries from the archives of classic detective fiction, from familiar Golden Age names like Agatha Christie and John Dickson Carr, to lesser-known authors like Patricia Moyes and Mavis Doriel Hay.
The setting is always so important in a detective novel because it can be worked into the mystery plot in such interesting ways–a tide or snow can reveal or obscure clues, bodies can be hid in interesting places, nature and weather can trap suspects in an isolated location. So you’ll find in these books that the authors have used the wintry settings to great effect, either for key plot points or for adding festive trappings that increase the tension–or perhaps relieve it.
Happy solving, and happy wintering!
Best Christmas Mysteries and Winter Thrillers
The Sittaford Mystery by Agatha Christie (also published as The Murder at Hazelmoor), 1931
One snowy winter night on Dartmoor in the south of England, six people in an isolated estate decide to have a séance to pass the time. What could possibly go wrong? It’s all fun and games until the group receives a cryptic message from beyond that seems to indicate a murder has been committed nearby.
Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie, 1934
Famous Belgian sleuth Hercule Poirot is traveling on the luxurious Orient Express when the train gets stuck in a snowdrift in the dead of night. The next morning, one of the passengers is dead from multiple stab wounds, his compartment locked from the inside. With the train still stranded and full of passengers, Poirot must unmask the killer in their midst.
Note: If you’re an Agatha Christie fan, you might be interested in my full list of all her novels, as well as the printable checklist in my shop.
The Nine Tailors by Dorothy L. Sayers, 1934
It’s a snow-swept New Year’s Eve and Lord Peter Wimsey is motoring through the bleak and marshy countryside of East Anglia when he finds himself stuck in a ditch. While waiting for his car to be repaired, Lord Peter ends up helping the local bell ringers to ring in the new year in the parish church (the “tailors” of the book’s title refer to bell-ringing). No one can foresee what the new year will turn up: an unidentified corpse, rumors of lost jewels, and long-buried secrets of the past coming to light at last.
The Nine Tailors is Sayers’s ninth Lord Peter novel, but it is a standalone novel in the sense that it doesn’t develop his love interest begun in Strong Poison.
The White Priory Murders by Carter Dickson, 1934
Carter Dickson is the pen name used by John Dickson Carr for his novels featuring the detective Sir Henry Merrivale. In this “impossible crime” mystery, a Hollywood actress is visiting an English estate when she’s found beaten to death in a pavilion surrounded by “a hundred straight feet of unmarked snow on every side.” The snow had stopped falling just shortly after the victim was last seen alive, so how are there no traces? The solution displays the ingenuity Carr is always known for.
The Hollow Man by John Dickson Carr (also published as The Three Coffins), 1935
Full of snowy, Gothic-esque atmosphere, The Hollow Man gives us not one but two impossible murders. First, a man is found dead in a locked room at the top of his house, with no footprints in the snow outside. Then, another man is murdered in an empty street with witnesses at either end–yet no one saw the murderer. And once again, there are no tracks in the snow. This is one of Carr’s most famous novels, and one of the most lauded locked room mysteries ever written. However, readers should be aware that during a lecture within the book on how locked room crimes can be committed, detective Dr. Gideon Fell spoils the plots of several other locked room mysteries by real authors!
Thou Shell of Death by Nicholas Blake (Cecil Day-Lewis), 1936
Cecil Day-Lewis would become the Poet Laureate of the United Kingdom in 1968, but earlier in his career he published twenty novels under the pseudonym Nicholas Blake. In this novel, World War I ace pilot Fergus O’Brien has been receiving death threats predicting his impending murder on Boxing Day. O’Brien decides it would be a clever idea to gather all his potential enemies in one house for a Christmas party–along with amateur detective Nigel Strangeways, to keep an eye on things.
Amazon | Bookshop.org
The Santa Klaus Murder by Mavis Doriel Hay, 1936
In this classic country-house mystery, a man in a Santa suit discovers Sir Osmond–the head of the family–shot dead. Suspects abound, as most of Sir Osmond’s numerous relations preferred him dead and certainly had motive to make him so. The only one lacking a motive is Santa Klaus himself!
Hay wrote just three detective novels, but they hold up among the works of her Golden Age contemporaries.
Mystery in White by J. Jefferson Farjeon, 1937
On Christmas Eve, a group of strangers decide to leave their snowbound train to seek shelter. They discover a cozy house all prepared for Christmas, with fires blazing in the hearth…but not a soul in sight! Farjeon does an excellent job weaving multiple layers of threats (weather, relational, impending crime) to sustain the tension from the first chapter to the last.
Hercule Poirot’s Christmas by Agatha Christie (also published as Murder for Christmas and as A Holiday for Murder), 1938
Unlikeable patriarch Simeon Lee gathers his large family together for the holidays…and then upsets everyone by telephoning his attorney in front of them and announcing his intention to change his will. On Christmas Eve there’s a tremendous commotion in Simeon’s bedroom and the family must break down his door to get inside, only to discover the old man brutally murdered, with no culprit in sight. Poirot assists in the investigation of this brilliant case, one of Agatha Christie’s few locked-room mysteries.
There Came Both Mist and Snow by Michael Innes (also published as A Comedy of Terrors), 1940
This holiday mystery features Innes’s series detective John Appleby of the London Metropolitan Police. An extended family gather for the Christmas holidays in Yorkshire, but one of them gets shot in the study just as Inspector Appleby is paying a visit. Each of the houseguests have their own fantastical theories as to the crime, and they all get a turn to expound!
Death and the Dancing Footman by Ngaio Marsh, 1941
A house party full of people who hate each other get snowed in by a blizzard. With tensions running so high, perhaps it’s no surprise that someone gets murdered! Series detective Inspector Roderick Alleyn is called in to solve the crime. Marsh said this was one of her favourites among her novels.
Rim of the Pit by Hake Talbot, 1944
A spooky and quirky tale set in the wilds of northern New England, this mystery features a séance, a logging camp, and even the mythical wendigo. Hake Talbot was the pen name for Henning Nelms, who wrote just two mystery novels. Rim of the Pit is a locked room mystery, which is quite fitting as Nelms’s primary occupation was as a stage magician!
The Honjin Murders by Seishi Yokomizo, 1946
Mystery novels flourished in Japan in the first decades of the 1900s just as they did in Great Britain and the United States. By the time Yokomizo published The Honjin Murders in 1946, which debuted his series detective Kosuke Kindaichi, the genre was well underway. Yokomizo was a master of the Honkaku (or “orthodox’) style of detective fiction, which is known for involving complex fair-play plots that can be solved by astute logical deduction. In this chilling tale, a happy newlywed couple are stabbed to death on their wedding night with a katana sword. The bloody sword is found on the snow outside their bedroom–but what’s missing from the snow are footprints.
An English Murder by Cyril Hare, 1951
A family gathers at their ancestral hall for a somber Christmas gathering; the lord of the manor is impoverished and dying, and as legalities would have it, he will be the last to hold the family title. After an awkward Christmas Eve dinner, the guests gather in the drawing room to count down to Christmas. But before the clock finishes striking midnight, one of the guests is murdered in plain sight. And little do the guests know, this victim won’t be the only casualty of this chilling holiday.
Death in Ambush by Susan Gilruth, 1952
Death in Ambush is a light, cozy mystery set in a village in Kent. It’s a bit different in that it’s narrated in the first person. Liane “Lee” Crauford is an outsider to the village, looking forward to visiting her friends for a few quiet weeks before Christmas. But the holiday peace is ruptured when a local resident dies under mysterious circumstances. Lee and her friend Detective-Inspector Hugh Gordon team up to unravel the puzzle.
Gilruth wrote seven detective novels in the 1950s and 60s featuring the Lee and Hugh Gordon duo, although only two of the novels are currently in print.
Dead Men Don’t Ski by Patricia Moyes, 1959
This is a non-Christmas winter mystery set in the dazzling and dangerous Italian Alps. Middle-aged couple Henry and Emmy Tibbett are on a skiing holiday with a secret agenda–Scotland Yard wants Henry to sniff out a smuggling ring that may have their headquarters at the ski resort. This was Moyes’s debut novel; she went on to write over a dozen more novels featuring the Tibbetts.
Tied Up in Tinsel by Ngaio Marsh, 1972
After someone gets murdered in the stately home where his wife is working on an art commission during the Christmas holidays, Roderick Alleyn once again finds himself faced with a Yuletide mystery. One thing that’s quite odd about this home is that it’s staffed by ex-convicts, all tried for murder. Amidst a plethora of Christmas trappings and traditions, Alleyn and his wife must root out the killer moving in the shadows.
What are your favourite Christmas and winter mystery books?

